Citing Uncodified Sections of Law by California Courts
Citing Uncodified Sections of Law by California Courts By Chris Micheli In California statutory interpretation, there is no precise statistical tracker or empirical count documenting exactly how frequently the state’s appellate courts cite uncodified intent sections versus codified findings when interpreting clear language of statutory text. However, looking at California’s established framework for statutory interpretation, legal scholars and appellate practices reveal several clear patterns regarding how the courts of this state treat these two mechanisms when dealing with unambiguous statutory text: 1. The Core Rule: Plain Language Beats Extrinsic Aids As a baseline rule, California appellate courts repeatedly hold that, if a statute’s language is clear and unambiguous, its plain meaning governs and there is no need to consider extrinsic aids when interpreting a statute. As a result, the courts in this state repeatedly explain that, when the statutory text is completely...