Poking Holes in Your Own Draft: How to Read Your Bill Like a Judge
Poking Holes in Your Own Draft: How to Read Your Bill Like a Judge By Chris Micheli When drafting a bill or even extensive amendments to a bill, I believe it is important to review your preliminary work from the perspective of the judicial branch of state government, which will have the final say regarding what your statutory language actually means. Just like the bill drafting attorneys at California’s Office of Legislative Counsel, outside attorneys, legislative committee counsel and consultants, staff, lobbyists, and others who work extensively with bills and amendments should examine their language using a “judge’s lens” test. This is when the legislative drafter puts aside their work for 24 hours and approaches their draft language as a skeptical judge looking for ambiguities would, rather than as a policy advocate, for example. ...