How Can a Higher Vote Threshold Be Imposed on Bills in the California Legislature?

How Can a Higher Vote Threshold Be Imposed on Bills in the California Legislature? By Chris Micheli

The California Constitution, in Article IV, Section 8(b)(3), clearly states the following: “No bill may be passed unless, by rollcall vote entered in the journal, a majority of the membership of each house concurs.” As a result, in the state Constitution, a simple majority of the Assembly (i.e., 41 affirmative votes) and Senate (i.e., 21 affirmative votes) are required for passage of a bill.

Nonetheless, observers of the legislative process will know that there are higher vote thresholds required for passage of a bill. Some are obvious because they are also found in the state Constitution. For example, in Article IV, Section 8(d), it provides for urgency clause bills: “In each house the section and the bill shall be passed separately, each by rollcall vote entered in the journal, two thirds of the membership concurring.”

But what about a bill that requires a super-majority vote and that vote threshold is found in a statute? How can a statute prevail over this constitutional requirement of a majority vote? One must look to another Article to find the answer.

Article II, Section 10 of the California Constitution explains this anomaly of where a statute can prevail over the constitutional vote requirement. Section 10(c) provides the following: “The Legislature may amend or repeal an initiative statute by another statute that becomes effective only when approved by the electors unless the initiative statute permits amendment or repeal without the electors’ approval.”

This section of the state Constitution generally prohibits the Legislature from amending a statutory initiative that was adopted by the voters, unless the initiative language itself allows amendment. For example, the Political Reform Act of 1974 was adopted by the statewide electorate as Proposition 9, which was a statutory initiative because it adds the PRA of 1974 to the Government Code.

Among the PRA’s provisions is Section 81012(a) of the Government Code, which provides the following: “This title may be amended to further its purposes by statute, passed in each house by rollcall vote entered in the journal, two-thirds of the membership concurring and signed by the Governor, if at least 12 days prior to passage in each house the bill in its final form has been delivered to the commission for distribution to the news media and to every person who has requested the commission to send copies of such bills to that person.”

As a result, the People of the State of California authorizes the Legislature to make certain amendments to the PRA of 1974 with a 2/3 vote threshold. This higher vote threshold is found in a statute contained in the Government Code. That is why a statute can contain a higher vote threshold than that which is contained in the state Constitution.

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Another Reason to Limit Bill Introductions?

Another Reason to Limit Bill Introductions?  By Chris Micheli             As I did my final review of Governor Newsom’s actions on the 1,046 bills sent to him after the 2023 Legislative Session, I noticed that some of the Governor’s veto messages provide additional rationales for limiting bill introductions.             Out of 156 vetoes from the 2023 Session, the number one reason for the Governor’s veto was budget concerns or cost pressures. In fact, 41% of the vetoes used that basis. That by itself is not a reason to limit bill introductions, but another statistic may provide such a reason…             By my count, just over 1/3 of the bills vetoed by Governor Newsom likely should not have been sent to his Desk and, arguably, should not have made it through the process at all. In fact, perhaps they should not h...
Read more

Frequently Asked Questions about California’s Budget Process

Frequently Asked Questions about California’s Budget Process  By Chris Micheli             What are the main parts of the California state budget? They are the Budget Bill, Budget Bill Junior, Trailer Bills, and Supplemental Reports.             What is the Budget Bill? This bill contains the appropriations and “Budget Bill Language”. Note that only a Budget Bill (or BBJ) can contain multiple appropriations. It requires a majority vote for passage and the bill takes effect immediately. There is just one Budget Bill. What is the “Budget Bill Jr.”? This is the bill that amends the main Budget Bill by making changes to multiple appropriations. There are often multiple BBJs. What is a Trailer Bill? This bill makes the statutory changes needed to implement the budget. It is the same as any other bill, but it takes effect immediately with a majority vote if it contain...
Read more

Can Any Bill Call an Election?

Can Any Bill Call an Election?  By Chris Micheli             In June 2024, we saw two bills that contain a provision to call an election.             Both bills contain a “plus” section at the end of the bill, which is an uncodified statute, stating the following: “this act calls an election within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.” Such a measure only requires a majority vote, unless some other constitutional provision requires a higher vote threshold (e.g., a tax increase). What is the basis for this statement? Section 8(c)(3) of Article IV of the state Constitution provides: “ Statutes calling elections, statutes providing for tax levies or appropriations for the usual current expenses of the State, and urgency statutes shall go into effect immediately upon their enactment.” However, there is no further gui...
Read more